Skip to content
Tyrone Software
Backtest Commodities

Does New York follow London's direction in metals and oil?

One bar per Commodities market on a 0 to 100 percent scale, all close to the 50 percent line
Period
–
Period length
2005 – 2026
Data
1-hour candles built from one-minute data
Sample
32,823 market-days from 7 markets (about 4,690.0 trading days each)
Source
OANDA CFD one-minute mid prices · New York trading days
50.4% of the time New York closed in the same direction as London
48.9–51.7% the range across the 7 markets
48.5% of the time London closed in the same direction as Asia
32,750 London–New York pairs counted

A session's direction is simple: did it close above or below its open? We asked whether the next session tends to go the same way, for every trading day of 7 markets from 2005 to September 30, 2026: Gold (XAU/USD), Silver (XAG/USD), Palladium (XPD/USD), Platinum (XPT/USD), Copper (XCU/USD), WTI crude oil and Brent crude oil.

Forex session times used here (New York time)

Every trading day runs from 17:00 to 17:00 New York time and is cut into three sessions that do not overlap, so each hour belongs to exactly one of them:

  • Asia: 17:00 to 02:00 (9 hours, starting the evening before)
  • London: 02:00 to 08:00 (6 hours, before New York opens)
  • New York: 08:00 to 17:00 (9 hours, including the London afternoon)

The sessions are not the same length. If time were all that mattered, Asia and New York would each get 37.5% of anything and London 25%. Every result below should be read against those numbers.

For this study the session lengths do not matter: it only compares the direction of one session with the next.

New York after London

Taken together, New York closed in the same direction as London on 50.4% of days. Market by market, the lowest was Silver at 48.9% and the highest WTI crude oil at 51.7%. 7 of the 7 markets are within two points of 50%.

London after Asia

London followed Asia's direction on 48.5% of days, a little below a coin flip. Markets in the same group move together, so the totals overstate how sure we can be.

Year by year

Over the 13 full years in which all 7 markets traded, the yearly share for London to New York stayed between 47.7% (2023) and 52.7% (2016), on both sides of 50%, so there is no steady lean in either direction. The markets of a group move together, so swings of a few points in a single year are ordinary noise. The direction of one session tells you essentially nothing about the direction of the next.

Why publish a result that found nothing?

"London sets the direction for the day" is a popular idea, and this is what it looks like when counted on years of data. A clear "no" is useful: it saves time, and any rule built on session direction has to beat these numbers, after costs, before it is worth anything.

Results by market

All years together, one row per market; the last row adds the markets together. Every value is a percentage of the days counted. Pick a market's name to see it year by year.

Commodities

7 markets
Does New York follow London's direction in metals and oil?: Commodities, all years, percent of days
Market Days London → New York Asia → London
Gold (XAU/USD) 5100 49.648.6
Silver (XAG/USD) 5096 48.947.6
Palladium (XPD/USD) 3746 51.447.1
Platinum (XPT/USD) 4257 50.348.6
Copper (XCU/USD) 3545 49.249.1
WTI crude oil 5580 51.749.1
Brent crude oil 5499 51.549.2
All commodities 32823 50.448.5

Year by year

Brent crude oil: 5499 complete trading days, 2005-04-08 to 2026-09-30.

  • The line in each bar marks 50%, a coin flip.
  • Bars, top to bottom: new york closes in the same direction as london; london closes in the same direction as asia.
Brent crude oil, year by year, percent of days
Year Days London → New York Asia → London Chart
2005 174 52.951.9
2006 254 55.548.0
2007 254 47.249.8
2008 255 52.555.9
2009 252 48.648.8
2010 252 49.249.6
2011 257 53.351.6
2012 255 52.254.2
2013 258 52.944.7
2014 258 52.750.6
2015 258 55.349.0
2016 258 58.151.2
2017 257 47.146.7
2018 258 47.343.0
2019 258 48.645.3
2020 259 53.746.3
2021 257 55.147.5
2022 258 48.853.1
2023 257 49.048.6
2024 259 49.248.8
2025 258 51.249.0
2026* 193 52.350.8
All years 5499 51.549.2

Every value is a percentage of the days counted. * 2026 runs until 2026-09-30.

How this was measured

  • Data: OANDA CFD one-minute mid prices (halfway between bid and ask). They are grouped into 1-hour candles in New York time, so US daylight saving time is followed automatically, including the older rules before 2007.
  • Trading day: 17:00 to 17:00 New York time, Monday to Friday. Asia 17:00–02:00, London 02:00–08:00, New York 08:00–17:00.
  • Which days count: a day needs at least one traded hour in every session and at least 75% of the usual number of trading hours for that market in that year. Holidays and half days drop out this way.
  • Which years count: a market's year is used only if it has at least 100 complete days. Years where a market did not trade in all three sessions are therefore left out for that market.
  • Ties: when two sessions reach exactly the same price, the earlier session gets it.
  • Totals: "together" simply adds up the market-days of the 7 markets. Markets in the same group move together (the crosses share currencies, the US indices move as one), so 32,823 market-days are not 32,823 independent observations.
  • Year by year in the text: only full calendar years in which every one of the 7 markets has data are used, so the group is the same in every year. The current, unfinished year is not part of that range (it is in the tables, marked with *).
  • Period: 2005 (or the first year with full data for a market) to September 30, 2026.
  • Direction: a session is up if its close is above its open, down if below. Sessions that close exactly at their open are left out of that comparison.

Historical statistics for research and education, not trading advice. Past market behaviour does not guarantee future results.

Keep reading
Stacked bars showing which session made the daily high in each Commodities market
54.6%of daily highs were made in the New York session (time share: 37.5%)
Commodities

Which session makes the daily high and low in metals and oil?

We checked which session printed the high and the low of every trading day in 7 metal and oil markets since 2005. New York printed 54.6% of the highs, above its time share.

  • Gold (XAU/USD)
  • Silver (XAG/USD)
  • Palladium (XPD/USD)
  • Platinum (XPT/USD)
  • +3
Stacked bars showing which session had the biggest range in each Commodities market
75.1%of days had New York as the biggest session
Commodities

How much of the day's range does each session cover in metals and oil?

For every trading day since 2005 we measured how much of the day's range each session covered in 7 metal and oil markets. New York had the biggest range on 75.1% of days.

  • Gold (XAU/USD)
  • Silver (XAG/USD)
  • Palladium (XPD/USD)
  • Platinum (XPT/USD)
  • +3

Technologies

  • Python
  • PHP
  • Laravel
  • Django
  • PostgreSQL
  • MySQL
  • HTML5
  • CSS3
  • Bootstrap